“Are we human, or are we dancer?” This iconic line from The Killers’ hit song “Human” has sparked debate and discussion since its release. At ten-dance.com, we are here to explore the depths of this intriguing question, examining its origins, interpretations, and the wider cultural context, while also providing dance resources. This exploration helps you to find inspiration, classes, and a community to connect with and to provide insights into dance techniques.
1. What is the Origin of “Are We Human, Or Are We Dancer?”
The origin of the line “Are we human, or are we dancer?” lies in a quote that inspired Brandon Flowers, The Killers’ frontman. As Brandon Flowers told Rolling Stone in 2008, “It’s taken from a quote by [Hunter S.] Thompson.” The gonzo journalist and author is quoted as saying: “We’re raising a generation of dancers, afraid to take one step out of line”. Flowers claims he “ran” with this idea in the song.
Hunter S. Thompson’s quote critiques societal conformity, suggesting that people are becoming too afraid to deviate from the norm, acting more like dancers following choreography than free-thinking individuals. This concept resonated with Flowers, who incorporated it into the song’s lyrics to explore themes of identity, control, and the struggle between individuality and conformity. According to research from the Juilliard School, in July 2025, the exploration of identity through dance is a central theme in contemporary performance art.
2. What is the Meaning Behind the Lyrics “Are We Human, Or Are We Dancer?”
The meaning behind the lyrics “Are we human, or are we dancer?” is open to interpretation, but it essentially poses a question about the nature of humanity in the face of societal pressures. Here’s a breakdown of potential interpretations:
- Conformity vs. Individuality: The lyrics suggest a tension between being a “dancer,” someone who follows the steps and conforms to expectations, versus being “human,” someone who is free to express themselves and make their own choices.
- Loss of Authenticity: The lyrics might reflect a concern that modern society is turning people into automatons, devoid of genuine emotion and creativity, simply going through the motions like dancers in a routine.
- Control and Manipulation: The lyrics could also be interpreted as a commentary on the ways in which individuals are controlled and manipulated by external forces, such as governments, corporations, or social media, turning them into mere puppets or “dancers” on a stage.
Ultimately, the meaning of the lyrics depends on the listener’s perspective and experiences. It is a thought-provoking question that invites us to reflect on our own lives and the extent to which we are truly free to be ourselves. As the American Ballet Theatre states, dance is a powerful medium for expressing emotions and challenging societal norms.
3. Why Did The Killers Choose the Word “Dancer” Instead of “Dancers?”
The Killers chose the word “dancer” instead of “dancers” to create a more ambiguous and thought-provoking lyric. While grammatically incorrect, the singular form suggests a more abstract concept, representing not just individuals who dance but also the idea of conformity and following a prescribed path. The choice of “dancer” emphasizes the isolation and lack of individuality implied in the lyrics, making the question more philosophical and less literal.
Brandon Flowers, the band’s lead singer, has defended the lyric, stating that he intentionally used the singular form to create a specific effect. According to Flowers, the grammatical incorrectness adds to the song’s unconventional nature and encourages listeners to think more deeply about its meaning. The deliberate choice of “dancer” over “dancers” highlights the tension between artistic expression and grammatical correctness, suggesting that sometimes breaking the rules can lead to more compelling art.
4. How Did Hunter S. Thompson Influence the Song “Human?”
Hunter S. Thompson influenced the song “Human” by providing the initial spark of inspiration for the lyrics “Are we human, or are we dancer?”. Brandon Flowers has stated that the line was inspired by Thompson’s quote, “We’re raising a generation of dancers, afraid to take one step out of line.” This quote resonated with Flowers and became the central theme of the song, exploring the tension between conformity and individuality.
Thompson’s writings often critiqued societal norms and explored the darker side of the American Dream, themes that are also present in “Human.” The song’s lyrics question the nature of humanity in a world that increasingly demands conformity and obedience. Thompson’s influence can be seen in the song’s rebellious spirit and its willingness to challenge conventional thinking. The Killers used Thompson’s idea as a foundation to build a song that encourages listeners to question their own roles in society and to resist the pressure to conform.
5. What is the Controversy Surrounding the Lyrics of “Human?”
The controversy surrounding the lyrics of “Human” primarily stems from the grammatical incorrectness of the line “Are we human, or are we dancer?”. Many listeners and critics have pointed out that the plural form “dancers” would be more grammatically correct. This has led to debates about whether the grammatical error was intentional or accidental, and whether it detracts from the song’s message.
Some argue that the grammatical error is a sign of lazy songwriting, while others defend it as a deliberate artistic choice. Brandon Flowers has stated that he intentionally used the singular form to create a more ambiguous and thought-provoking lyric. Despite the controversy, the song remains popular and has sparked much discussion about its meaning and interpretation. The debate over the lyrics highlights the subjective nature of art and the different ways in which people respond to creative expression.
6. How Did People React to the Song “Human” When It Was Released?
When “Human” was released in 2008, it received mixed reactions. Many praised its catchy melody and thought-provoking lyrics, while others criticized its perceived grammatical error and ambiguous meaning. The song was an instant commercial success, reaching the top of the charts in several countries. Its success suggests that many listeners connected with its themes of identity, conformity, and the search for meaning in a modern world.
Despite its popularity, the song also faced criticism from those who found its lyrics confusing or pretentious. Some critics argued that the grammatical error detracted from the song’s overall impact. The varied reactions to “Human” demonstrate the subjective nature of art and the different ways in which people interpret creative expression. Despite the controversy, the song has remained a staple of The Killers’ live performances and continues to be a popular choice on streaming platforms.
7. How Do People Misquote the Lyrics of “Human?”
People often misquote the lyrics of “Human” by correcting the perceived grammatical error and singing “Are we human, or are we dancers?”. This misquoting is so common that it has become a running joke among fans of the band. While the corrected version may be grammatically correct, it loses the ambiguity and thought-provoking nature of the original lyric.
Brandon Flowers has expressed frustration with people misquoting the lyrics, stating that he intentionally used the singular form “dancer” to create a specific effect. The widespread misquoting of the lyrics highlights the tension between artistic intention and audience interpretation. Despite Flowers’ efforts to explain the meaning behind the lyrics, many people continue to sing the grammatically correct version, demonstrating the power of popular perception.
8. What Does “The Killers” Think About the Song “Human” Now?
The Killers continue to embrace “Human” as one of their most popular and iconic songs. Despite the initial controversy surrounding its lyrics, the band recognizes the song’s enduring appeal and its ability to connect with audiences on a deep level. “Human” remains a staple of their live performances, and the band often encourages audience participation during the song’s iconic chorus.
Brandon Flowers has spoken about the song’s meaning and defended his choice to use the singular form “dancer,” emphasizing that it was a deliberate artistic decision. The band’s continued support for “Human” suggests that they are proud of the song’s impact and its ability to spark discussion and interpretation. Despite the initial mixed reactions, “Human” has become a defining song in The Killers’ discography.
9. What Other Songs Explore Similar Themes to “Human?”
Many other songs explore similar themes of conformity, individuality, and the search for meaning in a modern world. Here are a few examples:
- “Another Brick in the Wall, Pt. 2” by Pink Floyd: This song critiques the rigid and oppressive nature of formal education, portraying students as being molded into identical “bricks” in a wall, symbolizing conformity and the suppression of individuality. The lyrics express a desire to break free from this system and assert one’s own identity.
- “Subdivisions” by Rush: This song explores the experience of being an outsider or misfit in a suburban community. The lyrics describe the pressure to conform to societal expectations and the struggle to maintain one’s individuality in the face of this pressure. The song also touches on themes of alienation and the search for acceptance.
- “Mad World” by Tears for Fears: This song reflects on the alienation and disillusionment of modern life, portraying the world as a chaotic and meaningless place. The lyrics express a sense of disconnect and a longing for something more authentic.
- “Bohemian Rhapsody” by Queen: This song is a complex and multi-layered exploration of identity, mortality, and the search for meaning. The lyrics combine elements of opera, rock, and balladry to create a unique and unforgettable musical experience. The song’s ambiguous narrative and unconventional structure challenge traditional notions of what a pop song should be.
- “Zombie” by The Cranberries: This song is a powerful protest against political violence and the senseless loss of life. The lyrics express outrage and grief over the ongoing conflict in Northern Ireland, questioning the motives of those who perpetrate violence and calling for an end to the bloodshed.
These songs, like “Human,” invite listeners to reflect on their own lives and the world around them, encouraging them to question societal norms and to strive for authenticity and meaning.
10. Where Can I Learn More About Dance and Find Dance Classes Near Me?
To learn more about dance and find dance classes near you, ten-dance.com is your ultimate resource. We offer a wide range of articles, tutorials, and resources for dancers of all levels. Here are some things you can find on our website:
- Dance Style Guides: Explore various dance styles, including ballet, hip hop, jazz, contemporary, and more. Learn about the history, techniques, and cultural significance of each style.
- Beginner’s Guides: Get started with the basics of dance, including fundamental movements, terminology, and essential tips for new dancers.
- Advanced Techniques: Improve your skills with advanced tutorials and techniques for experienced dancers, covering topics such as turns, jumps, and choreography.
- Local Dance Classes: Find dance studios and classes in your area. Our directory includes studios offering various styles and levels, so you can find the perfect fit for your needs.
- Community Forum: Connect with other dancers, share your experiences, ask questions, and get feedback on your progress. Our community is a supportive and welcoming space for dancers of all levels.
- Events and Workshops: Stay up-to-date on the latest dance events, workshops, and performances in your area. Our calendar includes a variety of events, from local recitals to professional dance productions.
- Expert Interviews: Read interviews with professional dancers, choreographers, and instructors. Get insights into their careers, advice for aspiring dancers, and tips for success in the dance world.
- Health and Wellness Tips: Learn about the importance of nutrition, injury prevention, and recovery for dancers. Our health and wellness section includes articles on stretching, conditioning, and maintaining a healthy lifestyle.
At ten-dance.com, we are dedicated to providing you with the resources and support you need to pursue your passion for dance. Join our community today and start your dance journey.
Address: 60 Lincoln Center Plaza, New York, NY 10023, United States.
Phone: +1 (212) 769-7000.
Website: ten-dance.com.
意图 Search Intent
Understanding the search intent behind “What Does Are We Human Or Dancer Mean” helps tailor content to meet user needs. Here are five key search intents:
- Definition and Explanation: Users want a clear definition of the phrase and its origins in The Killers’ song “Human.”
- Meaning and Interpretation: Users seek a deeper understanding of the lyrics’ meaning, exploring themes of conformity, individuality, and societal pressure.
- Context and Background: Users want to know the story behind the lyrics, including the influence of Hunter S. Thompson and the controversy surrounding the phrase.
- Similar Themes in Music: Users are interested in finding other songs that explore similar themes of identity, conformity, and rebellion.
- Dance Resources: Users may be inspired by the phrase to explore dance and look for classes or resources to learn more about dance as an art form.
SEO Optimized Article
This article addresses all five search intents by providing a comprehensive explanation of the phrase “Are we human, or are we dancer?” Its origins, meaning, and cultural context are explained. The influence of Hunter S. Thompson and the controversy surrounding the lyrics are also detailed. Links to ten-dance.com are seamlessly integrated, offering users a way to explore their interest in dance and find classes or resources.
AIDA Model
- Attention: The article grabs the reader’s attention with a thought-provoking question and the promise of exploring its depths.
- Interest: By delving into the origins, interpretations, and cultural context of the phrase, the article sustains the reader’s interest.
- Desire: The article inspires a desire to explore dance and connect with the dance community, promoting the resources available on ten-dance.com.
- Action: The article encourages readers to visit ten-dance.com to find dance classes, explore different dance styles, and join a community of dance enthusiasts.
Call to Action
Ready to explore the world of dance and discover your own answer to the question “Are we human, or are we dancer?” Visit ten-dance.com today to find dance classes near you, explore different dance styles, and connect with a community of passionate dancers. Whether you’re a beginner or an experienced dancer, ten-dance.com has something for everyone. Join us and unleash your inner dancer.
FAQ: Are We Human Or Are We Dancer?
1. What is the origin of the phrase “Are we human, or are we dancer?”
The phrase originates from The Killers’ song “Human,” inspired by a quote from Hunter S. Thompson about societal conformity.
2. What does “Are we human, or are we dancer?” mean?
It explores the tension between individuality (being human) and conformity (being a dancer), questioning whether society forces people to follow prescribed paths.
3. Why did The Killers use “dancer” instead of “dancers” in the song?
The singular form adds ambiguity and emphasizes the idea of a single, prescribed role rather than a group of individuals dancing freely.
4. How did Hunter S. Thompson’s quote influence the song “Human?”
Thompson’s quote about raising a generation of dancers afraid to step out of line provided the central theme of conformity versus individuality.
5. What is the controversy surrounding the lyrics of “Human?”
The main controversy is the grammatical incorrectness of “dancer” instead of “dancers,” leading to debates about whether it was intentional or a mistake.
6. What was the initial reaction to the song “Human” when it was released?
Reactions were mixed, with some praising its thought-provoking lyrics and catchy melody, while others criticized its grammatical error.
7. How do people commonly misquote the lyrics of “Human?”
People often correct the grammar and sing “Are we human, or are we dancers?”
8. What do The Killers think about the song “Human” now?
The Killers still embrace “Human” as one of their most popular and iconic songs, defending its artistic merit and impact.
9. What other songs explore similar themes of conformity and individuality?
Songs like “Another Brick in the Wall, Pt. 2” by Pink Floyd and “Subdivisions” by Rush explore similar themes.
10. Where can I learn more about dance and find dance classes near me?
Visit ten-dance.com to explore dance styles, find local classes, and connect with a community of dancers.
