Since its premiere on FOX in 2005, So You Think You Can Dance has captivated audiences with its incredible display of dance talent. Central to the show’s appeal are the So You Think You Can Dance judges, the panel of experts tasked with discovering and nurturing the next generation of dance stars. From seasoned choreographers to industry veterans, these judges have provided insightful critiques, unforgettable moments, and shaped the careers of countless dancers. Let’s take a look back at the So You Think You Can Dance judges throughout the years, exploring their tenures and the reasons behind their departures.
The judging panel has seen numerous changes over its impressive run, reflecting the evolving landscape of dance and entertainment. Initially spearheaded by the show’s co-creator Nigel Lythgoe and the energetic Mary Murphy, the So You Think You Can Dance judges panel has welcomed a variety of personalities, each bringing their unique expertise and perspective to the stage. As we delve into the history of So You Think You Can Dance judges, we’ll uncover the dynamics, controversies, and legacies left by these influential figures in the world of dance.
The Reign of Nigel Lythgoe: A SYTYCD Constant
Nigel Lythgoe, a name synonymous with So You Think You Can Dance, was a fixture on the judging panel from the very first season. As co-creator of the show alongside Simon Fuller, Lythgoe brought his extensive experience as a television producer and choreographer to the So You Think You Can Dance judges table. For sixteen seasons, his sharp critiques and distinctive British wit were a hallmark of the show.
Lythgoe’s departure in March 2022 marked a significant shift for SYTYCD. While show producers remained tight-lipped about the reasons, Lythgoe himself indicated he was not invited back for season 17. Initially, there were plans for his return in season 18, but these were derailed when he stepped down amidst serious allegations of sexual assault in January 2024, claims he has denied. Lythgoe’s long tenure makes him one of the most recognizable So You Think You Can Dance judges and his exit left a noticeable void.
Mary Murphy and the Hot Tamale Train
Alongside Nigel Lythgoe for many seasons was Mary Murphy, known for her infectious enthusiasm and the iconic “Hot Tamale Train.” Murphy’s expertise in ballroom dance and her passionate commentary made her a fan favorite among the So You Think You Can Dance judges. Her energetic personality and signature train celebration became synonymous with high-energy performances on the show.
Murphy’s time as a So You Think You Can Dance judge wasn’t continuous. She was surprisingly let go ahead of the 2015 season, with her spokesperson citing contract issues at the time. While she did return for seasons 14 through 16, she was again absent from the lineup for season 17. Despite these breaks, Mary Murphy remains a cherished figure in SYTYCD history, remembered for her vibrant personality and dedication to dance.
Brief Tenures and Shifting Panels: Other SYTYCD Judges
While Lythgoe and Murphy were long-term fixtures, So You Think You Can Dance judges panel also saw a rotation of other notable figures. Adam Shankman, a choreographer with extensive Hollywood experience, joined for seasons 6 and 7. No official reason was given for his departure, but Shankman’s industry commitments likely played a role.
Mia Michaels, a celebrated choreographer known for her contemporary style, also had a brief stint as a So You Think You Can Dance judge in season 7. Michaels, who frequently choreographed for the show, stated in 2020 that she left to pursue other career opportunities. Her unique choreographic perspective was missed by many viewers.
Seasons 12 and 13 saw pop icons Paula Abdul and Jason Derulo join the So You Think You Can Dance judges. Abdul, replacing Murphy during contract negotiations, brought her American Idol judging experience to the show. Her departure after two seasons likely stemmed from touring commitments. Derulo’s exit after the same period remains less clear, though he maintained a positive relationship with the show, appearing in its 300th episode.
For season 13’s SYTYCD: The Next Generation, Maddie Ziegler, of Dance Moms fame, took a seat at the So You Think You Can Dance judges table. Her youthful perspective was tailored to the younger contestants of that season. As a special format season, her tenure was always intended to be for that season only.
Vanessa Hudgens added star power to seasons 14 and 15 of So You Think You Can Dance. While no official reason was announced for her departure, Hudgens’ busy acting career likely contributed to her leaving the panel.
The Modern Era and Recent SYTYCD Judges
In more recent seasons, So You Think You Can Dance judges panel has continued to evolve. Stephen “tWitch” Boss, a former contestant and All-Star, became a judge for season 15 and later season 17. His journey from contestant to judge was a heartwarming story for fans. Tragically, Boss passed away in December 2022, leaving a profound loss for the dance community and the show.
Laurieann Gibson and Dominic “D-Trix” Sandoval, both seasoned dance professionals, were So You Think You Can Dance judges for season 16. Gibson was initially slated to return for season 17, but the judging panel took a different direction after pandemic-related delays. Sandoval’s departure was part of this broader panel change.
Season 17 saw a significant shake-up with JoJo Siwa and Matthew Morrison joining the So You Think You Can Dance judges. However, Morrison’s time was cut short due to allegations of sending inappropriate messages to a contestant, which he denied. Leah Remini stepped in to replace Morrison mid-season. Remini’s departure after season 17 remains unexplained.
For season 18, SYTYCD welcomed back Allison Holker (Boss’s widow) and Maksim Chmerkovskiy as So You Think You Can Dance judges. This new panel signaled a fresh chapter for the show, blending familiar faces with new perspectives.
The Legacy of SYTYCD Judges
The So You Think You Can Dance judges have been integral to the show’s success and impact on the dance world. From the long-standing presence of Nigel Lythgoe and Mary Murphy to the diverse perspectives of judges like Stephen “tWitch” Boss and JoJo Siwa, each panel member has contributed to the show’s unique identity. While judges have come and gone, their collective passion for dance and commitment to nurturing talent has remained a constant, ensuring So You Think You Can Dance continues to discover and celebrate exceptional dancers. The ever-evolving panel of So You Think You Can Dance judges keeps the show fresh and engaging, promising exciting seasons to come for dance fans worldwide.
