Since its debut in 2005, So You Think You Can Dance (SYTYCD) has captivated audiences with its incredible talent and dynamic judging panel. The show’s judges are crucial, offering expertise and shaping careers. From seasoned choreographers to beloved alumni, the think you can dance judges have evolved, bringing fresh perspectives each season. Let’s dive into the history of the SYTYCD judges, exploring who they are, their contributions, and why changes occurred over the years.
The Pillars of the Panel: Nigel Lythgoe and Mary Murphy
For many seasons, So You Think You Can Dance was synonymous with two names on the judging panel: Nigel Lythgoe and Mary Murphy. Lythgoe, co-creator of the show, brought a producer’s eye and sharp critique from Season 1 through Season 16. His departure in March 2022 marked a significant shift. While initially, the reasons were unclear, Lythgoe himself tweeted he was not invited back for Season 17. Later, his planned return for Season 18 was derailed as he stepped down amidst sexual assault allegations, which he denied.
Nigel Lythgoe at So You Think You Can Dance, offering his expert critique.
Mary Murphy, known for her infectious energy and “Hot Tamale Train,” was another mainstay. Her expertise in ballroom and Latin dance, combined with her enthusiastic personality, made her a fan favorite. Murphy judged Seasons 1-6, 8-11, and 14-16. Her exit ahead of Season 17, like Lythgoe’s, signaled a new era for the think you can dance judges. While she was released from her contract before Season 12, she made triumphant returns, proving her enduring appeal.
Mary Murphy, the 'Hot Tamale Train' conductor, judging dancers with passion.
Season 17 and 18: A Fresh Judging Lineup
Season 17 ushered in a completely revamped panel of think you can dance judges. Stephen “tWitch” Boss, an SYTYCD alum and All-Star, brought his contestant and mentor experience to the table. Joining him were pop star JoJo Siwa and Broadway star Matthew Morrison. This trio aimed to discover the next generation of dance talent.
Stephen 'tWitch' Boss, former contestant and judge, bringing his unique perspective.
However, Morrison’s tenure was short-lived. He exited mid-season due to what was described as a “minor infraction,” later revealed to be allegations of sending inappropriate messages to a contestant. Morrison denied these claims. Leah Remini stepped in as his replacement, bringing her “dance enthusiast” perspective to complete Season 17.
Leah Remini, the 'dance enthusiast' judge, adding her celebrity insight to the panel.
For Season 18, SYTYCD continued to evolve its judging panel. Allison Holker, Boss’ widow and another beloved SYTYCD alum, joined alongside Dancing With the Stars veteran Maksim Chmerkovskiy. This pairing brought both SYTYCD expertise and broader dance competition experience to the think you can dance judges table.
Allison Holker, SYTYCD alum and judge, continuing tWitch's legacy on the show.
Maksim Chmerkovskiy, DWTS veteran judge, expanding the judging expertise.
Other Notable SYTYCD Judges Through the Years
Beyond the long-term judges, So You Think You Can Dance has featured a variety of talented individuals who have graced the panel for shorter periods, each leaving their mark on the show.
Adam Shankman, a choreographer with deep ties to SYTYCD, transitioned from mentor to judge for Seasons 6 and 7. His choreography background provided valuable insights for contestants. The reason for his departure as a judge was not publicly disclosed.
Adam Shankman, choreographer and former judge, contributing his expertise to the show.
Mia Michaels, another frequent choreographer and guest judge, took a permanent seat in Season 7. Known for her contemporary dance expertise and strong opinions, Michaels decided to pursue other career opportunities after one season as a judge.
Mia Michaels, renowned choreographer and judge, bringing her distinctive perspective.
Paula Abdul, known from American Idol, joined SYTYCD for Seasons 12 and 13, replacing Mary Murphy temporarily. Her pop star background and experience on judging panels brought a different flavor. Her touring schedule with New Kids on the Block and Boyz II Men likely conflicted with SYTYCD filming, leading to her exit.
Paula Abdul, pop icon and judge, bringing her star power to the SYTYCD panel.
Jason Derulo also judged Seasons 12 and 13 alongside Abdul. His perspective as a successful contemporary music artist added another dimension to the panel. Details surrounding his departure remain limited, though he maintained a positive connection with the show.
Jason Derulo, music artist and judge, adding a contemporary music perspective.
Season 13, SYTYCD: The Next Generation, featured Maddie Ziegler as a judge. The Dance Moms alum, herself a young dancer, was uniquely positioned to mentor the younger contestants. This season focused on younger dancers, a departure from the usual age range.
Maddie Ziegler, young dance star and judge, mentoring the next generation of dancers.
Vanessa Hudgens judged Seasons 14 and 15, bringing her High School Musical fame and dance background to the show. Her busy acting career was a likely factor in her departure after two seasons.
Vanessa Hudgens, actress and judge, adding Hollywood glamour to the panel.
Laurieann Gibson judged Season 16, bringing her experience as a choreographer and creative director. While initially slated to return for Season 17, plans changed after the pandemic delayed production.
Laurieann Gibson, choreographer and judge, contributing her creative direction expertise.
Dominic ‘D-Trix’ Sandoval, an SYTYCD alum and All-Star, also judged Season 16. His contestant and All-Star experience provided a unique viewpoint. Like Gibson, he did not return after the production hiatus.
Dominic ‘D-Trix’ Sandoval, SYTYCD alum judge, offering a contestant's perspective.
JoJo Siwa continued as a think you can dance judge for Season 18, showcasing her commitment to the show.
JoJo Siwa, returning judge, bringing continuity to the panel.
The Ever-Evolving Panel
The think you can dance judges panel has seen significant changes since its inception. From the long-standing presence of Nigel Lythgoe and Mary Murphy to the newer faces like JoJo Siwa, Allison Holker, and Maksim Chmerkovskiy, each judge has contributed to the show’s dynamic and success. The evolution of the panel reflects the show’s commitment to staying fresh and relevant, ensuring So You Think You Can Dance remains a premier platform for dance talent.