Released in 1990, Dances With Wolves quickly became a cinematic phenomenon, largely propelled by the compelling performance of Kevin Costner In Dances With Wolves. As Lieutenant John Dunbar, Costner not only starred but also directed this sweeping Western epic, a story that continues to resonate decades later. Upon revisiting this film, its brilliance is undeniable, a testament to its enduring quality and powerful storytelling. The narrative centers on Dunbar, a Civil War hero who finds himself stationed at a remote outpost on the South Dakota prairie. Initially isolated, he gradually encounters and forms a profound connection with a local Lakota Sioux tribe. This journey of cultural immersion leads him to adopt the Sioux name “Dances With Wolves” and ultimately integrate into their community. However, the encroaching U.S. Army views his transformation as treachery, setting the stage for conflict and forcing Dunbar to confront his loyalties. Alongside Costner, the film features memorable performances from Mary McDonnell and Graham Greene, adding depth and authenticity to this cinematic masterpiece.
Dances With Wolves is filmmaking at its finest. This three-hour epic Western seamlessly blends captivating narrative with stunning visuals, creating an immersive experience that truly engages the viewer. For those seeking an even richer experience, the extended director’s cut adds an hour of footage, further developing characters and enriching the narrative. Whether you opt for the theatrical or director’s cut, Dances With Wolves is a must-see film, a powerful exploration of cultural understanding and human connection.
Over the years, Dances With Wolves has faced certain criticisms, primarily centered around its portrayal of Native Americans and white characters. Some critics have argued that the film presents a romanticized view of Native American culture while simultaneously offering a negative depiction of white people. Before revisiting the film, these criticisms were considered, but upon re-examination, they largely fall apart. To label Dances With Wolves as simply “pro-Indian/anti-white” is a gross oversimplification of its nuanced and complex narrative. In reality, the film presents a far more balanced and authentic portrayal of the interactions between cultures during a tumultuous period in American history.
To understand the film’s balanced perspective, consider the following points:
-
The Pawnee tribe, encountered early in the film, are depicted as unequivocally hostile. Their brutal and merciless treatment of both white settlers and other Native American tribes challenges any notion of a uniformly virtuous portrayal of indigenous peoples. This depiction serves as a stark contrast and highlights the diversity within Native American cultures themselves.
-
Within the Lakota Sioux tribe, internal conflicts and varying opinions are present. Wind In His Hair, portrayed powerfully by Rodney A. Grant, initially advocates for Dunbar’s death, reflecting suspicion and hostility. This internal debate within the tribe showcases the complexity of their decision-making and avoids presenting them as a monolithic entity.
-
The film avoids painting all white characters with the same brush. Lieutenant Dunbar, the protagonist embodied by Kevin Costner in Dances With Wolves, is himself a white man driven by honor and empathy. Even Timmons, the uncouth wagon driver who escorts Dunbar, is not a villain. Despite his rough exterior, Timmons displays genuine kindness and loyalty, particularly in his poignant final moments. His concern for his mules and heartfelt farewell to Dunbar reveal a “heart of gold” beneath his unrefined demeanor, adding layers to the depiction of white characters.
-
Dances With Wolves is set against the backdrop of the Indian Wars, a period characterized by conflict and mistrust on both sides. The U.S. Army’s actions are portrayed within this historical context. While some soldiers may appear as “clueless,” they are largely depicted as carrying out orders within a system, not necessarily as inherently evil. This nuanced approach reflects the realities of the time rather than resorting to simplistic villainization.
-
Furthermore, the film acknowledges that not all Native Americans were unified in their resistance to white expansion. The presence of Native American scouts assisting the U.S. Army highlights the complex alliances and divisions that existed, further challenging any simplistic “us vs. them” narrative.
-
The Lakota Sioux tribe is not presented as living in a utopian paradise. They face hardships, internal disagreements, and uncertainty about the future. Their lives are depicted with realism, showcasing their resilience and humanity rather than portraying them as idealized figures. The harsh realities of their winter camp and the constant threat of encroaching white settlers demonstrate the challenges they faced.
-
The devastating depiction of bison annihilation is not an indictment of all white people, but a stark portrayal of a historical tragedy. This scene, along with the casual cruelty towards wildlife, reflects the destructive impact of westward expansion and resource exploitation, adding a layer of historical accuracy and social commentary to the film.
These examples demonstrate that Dances With Wolves, starring Kevin Costner in Dances With Wolves, offers a far more intricate and balanced portrayal of its characters and historical context than often acknowledged. It moves beyond simplistic stereotypes and delves into the complexities of human interaction and cultural understanding.
The narrative’s core premise, exploring the possibility of understanding and connection between cultures, remains compelling. The film examines what might happen when a white man sheds prejudice and seeks common ground with his Sioux neighbors, and conversely, when a Native American tribe is open enough to accept him. While the romantic relationship element might be seen as a touch of Hollywood embellishment, it serves to enhance the narrative’s emotional depth and overall appeal. Ultimately, Dances With Wolves presents this cross-cultural encounter in a believable and captivating manner.
Nearly 20 years after its release, Dances With Wolves remains a timeless cinematic achievement. Like all truly great films, its themes of understanding, empathy, and the human spirit continue to resonate powerfully with audiences today. It stands as a definitive example of why cinema holds such power, capable of transporting us to different worlds and fostering a deeper understanding of ourselves and others.
Filmed primarily in Western South Dakota, with additional locations in Wyoming, Nebraska, and Kansas, Dances With Wolves further grounds its narrative in a sense of place and authenticity.
Grade: A+
