Erin A. Craig’s House of Salt and Sorrows offers a captivating, darker take on the timeless fairy tale, “The Twelve Dancing Princesses,” a narrative that many might fondly recall through the animated film, Barbie and the Twelve Dancing Princesses. While Craig’s novel delves into shadowy mysteries and mature themes, the heart of both stories beats with the rhythm of sisterhood, secrets, and the allure of magical dances. For those charmed by tales of princesses and enchanted realms, exploring these different interpretations offers a rich tapestry of storytelling.
A Tale of Twelve Sisters and a Secret
House of Salt and Sorrows Lantern
At the core of Barbie and the Twelve Dancing Princesses is the story of Genevieve and her eleven sisters, each with distinct personalities but united by their love for dance and family. Much like the Thaumas sisters in House of Salt and Sorrows, these princesses face unique challenges. In the Barbie movie, their strict etiquette teacher, Dame Devin, threatens to extinguish their joy and individuality. This external threat mirrors the unseen menace that plagues Annaleigh and her sisters, creating a sense of suspense and prompting the audience to wonder about the source of the princesses’ woes.
The animated film beautifully portrays the sisters’ escape into a magical, hidden dance pavilion. This secret world, filled with flowing gowns and enchanting music, becomes their sanctuary. This element of a hidden, magical world resonates with the mysterious midnight balls in Craig’s novel, though the tone and purpose differ significantly. In Barbie, the magic is a source of joy and freedom, while in House of Salt and Sorrows, it is intertwined with darker, more enigmatic forces.
Themes of Family, Courage, and Discovery
Both narratives emphasize the strength of sisterhood. Genevieve and her sisters work together to overcome Dame Devin’s oppressive rules and protect their secret haven. This unity is a central theme, showcasing how family bonds can be a source of strength and resilience. Similarly, Annaleigh in House of Salt and Sorrows is driven by the loss of her sisters and her determination to protect the remaining ones, even amidst growing suspicion and fear.
The quest for discovery is another compelling element in Barbie and the Twelve Dancing Princesses. When Genevieve and her sisters realize their father is being poisoned, they embark on a journey to find the magical water lilies that can cure him. This proactive approach to solving their problems highlights their courage and resourcefulness. While Annaleigh’s journey is more of an internal investigation mixed with external threats, both stories feature protagonists who must unravel mysteries to save their loved ones and restore harmony to their world.
Enchantment for Different Audiences
Barbie and the Twelve Dancing Princesses delivers a lighthearted, family-friendly adventure, perfect for younger viewers. It celebrates individuality, the joy of dance, and the importance of family. The vibrant animation, catchy songs, and happy ending contribute to its enduring appeal.
On the other hand, House of Salt and Sorrows offers a more mature and atmospheric experience. It delves into darker themes of death, mystery, and the supernatural, appealing to young adult readers who enjoy gothic fantasy and intricate plots. While both are inspired by the same fairy tale, they cater to different age groups and preferences, demonstrating the versatility of “The Twelve Dancing Princesses” narrative.
Whether you prefer the animated charm of Barbie or the gothic allure of House of Salt and Sorrows, the story of twelve dancing princesses continues to enchant. Exploring both interpretations allows for a deeper appreciation of the fairy tale’s enduring themes and its capacity to inspire diverse and captivating stories.
