Since So You Think You Can Dance (SYTYCD) premiered on FOX in 2005, the show has captivated audiences with incredible dance talent and dynamic judging panels. These expert judges are crucial to the show’s success, tasked with discovering and nurturing the next generation of dance stars. From seasoned choreographers to industry veterans, the SYTYCD judges have brought a wealth of knowledge and personality to the stage. Let’s take a look back at the So You Think You Can Dance judges throughout the years, exploring who they are, their contributions, and the reasons behind their departures.
Nigel Lythgoe, a co-creator of the show, was a constant presence on the judging panel for the first 16 seasons. His sharp critiques and industry insight were a hallmark of SYTYCD. Alongside him for many seasons was Mary Murphy, known for her infectious energy and “Hot Tamale Train” enthusiasm. Together, they formed a core part of the SYTYCD judging experience. However, season 17 brought significant changes, with both Lythgoe and Murphy departing and new faces joining the search for America’s favorite dancer.
Nigel Lythgoe
Judge for: Seasons 1-16
Reason for exit: Nigel Lythgoe’s exit in 2022 marked the end of an era for SYTYCD. While producers didn’t officially state the reason for his departure after 16 seasons, Lythgoe himself mentioned on Twitter that he was not invited back for season 17. Initially, he planned a return for season 18. However, these plans changed when he stepped down amidst serious allegations of sexual assault in January 2024, which he has denied. Lythgoe’s influence on the show is undeniable, having helped shape its direction and mentor countless dancers.
Mary Murphy
Judge for: Seasons 1-6, 8-11, 14-16
Reason for exit: Mary Murphy, with her signature “Hot Tamale Train,” was a fan favorite judge known for her ballroom expertise and passionate feedback. She was surprisingly let go before season 12 in 2015 due to contract reasons, according to her spokesperson. Although she made a welcome return for seasons 14 through 16, Murphy was again not asked to return for season 17. Her absence was felt by many viewers who loved her spirited judging style.
Adam Shankman
Judge for: Seasons 6-7
Reason for exit: Adam Shankman, a renowned choreographer and director, transitioned from mentoring dancers behind the scenes to a permanent judge in season 6. He brought his extensive knowledge of choreography and performance to the panel. The reason for Shankman’s departure after season 7 was not publicly disclosed. His short but impactful time as a judge added a different perspective to the show’s dynamic.
Mia Michaels
Judge for: Season 7
Reason for exit: Mia Michaels, a celebrated contemporary choreographer, was a frequent guest and choreographer on SYTYCD before becoming a full-time judge in season 7. Known for her intense choreography and direct judging style, Michaels decided to leave after one season to pursue other career opportunities. In a 2020 interview with People Magazine, she expressed her desire to explore new paths after her time on the show.
Paula Abdul
Judge for: Seasons 12-13
Reason for exit: Paula Abdul, a pop icon and former American Idol judge, joined SYTYCD for seasons 12 and 13, replacing Mary Murphy during contract disagreements. Her experience in music and performance brought a different flavor to the judging panel. Abdul’s departure in 2012 was likely due to scheduling conflicts with her Total Package Tour with New Kids on the Block and Boyz II Men, which coincided with the SYTYCD filming schedule.
Jason Derulo
Judge for: Seasons 12-13
Reason for exit: Singer and dancer Jason Derulo also joined the judging panel for seasons 12 and 13 alongside Paula Abdul. His perspective as a successful recording artist and dancer was valuable to the contestants. The reasons for Derulo’s exit from SYTYCD are not widely known, but he did make a special appearance on the show’s 300th episode in June 2022, showing his continued connection to the show.
Maddie Ziegler
Judge for: Season 13
Reason for exit: Maddie Ziegler, known from Dance Moms and for her collaborations with Sia, was a judge for season 13, So You Think You Can Dance: The Next Generation. This season focused on younger dancers, and Ziegler, being a successful young dancer herself, served as a relatable judge and mentor. Her judging role was specific to The Next Generation format, which explains her departure after this season.
Vanessa Hudgens
Judge for: Seasons 14-15
Reason for exit: Actress and singer Vanessa Hudgens joined SYTYCD as a judge for seasons 14 and 15. Her background in performance and musical theatre provided a unique viewpoint on the panel. While no official reason was given for Hudgens’ departure, her busy acting career likely played a role in her decision to leave after two seasons.
Stephen ‘tWitch’ Boss
Judge for: Season 15, Season 17
Reason for exit: Stephen “tWitch” Boss, an SYTYCD alum and All-Star, became a judge in season 15 and later returned for season 17. His journey from contestant to judge was inspiring, and his positive energy was infectious. Tragically, Stephen “tWitch” Boss passed away by suicide in December 2022, leaving a profound loss for the dance community and SYTYCD family.
Laurieann Gibson
Judge for: Season 16
Reason for exit: Laurieann Gibson, a choreographer known for her work with major artists, was a judge in season 16. She brought a strong personality and high expectations to the judging panel. While initially considered to return for season 17 alongside Lythgoe and Murphy before the pandemic, the show took a different direction with its judging panel when it returned post-COVID.
Dominic ‘D-Trix’ Sandoval
Judge for: Season 16
Reason for exit: Dominic “D-Trix” Sandoval, another SYTYCD alum and All-Star, joined Gibson on the judging panel for season 16. His experience as a contestant and versatile dancer provided valuable insights. Like Gibson, D-Trix did not return after season 16 as the show’s judging lineup was revamped for its return after the pandemic-related hiatus.
Matthew Morrison
Judge for: Season 17
Reason for exit: Matthew Morrison, known for his role in Glee, was initially announced as a judge for season 17. However, he was abruptly dismissed mid-season due to allegations of sending inappropriate messages to a female contestant. Morrison denied these claims in June 2022, but his time on SYTYCD was cut short due to the controversy.
Leah Remini
Judge for: Season 17
Reason for exit: Leah Remini, actress and TV personality, stepped in to replace Matthew Morrison during season 17. Her enthusiasm and “dance enthusiast” perspective were welcomed by viewers. Remini has not publicly stated why she did not return to the SYTYCD judging panel after season 17.
JoJo Siwa
Judge for: Seasons 17-18
Reason for exit: JoJo Siwa, a dancer, singer, and social media personality, brought youthful energy and a strong connection to younger audiences as a judge in seasons 17 and 18. As of the latest information, there has been no announcement regarding JoJo Siwa’s departure from the show.
Allison Holker
Judge for: Season 18
Reason for exit: Allison Holker, an SYTYCD All-Star and wife of the late Stephen “tWitch” Boss, joined the judging panel for season 18. Her deep connection to the show and dance expertise made her a valuable addition. As of current information, there is no announced reason for her exit beyond season 18.
Maksim Chmerkovskiy
Judge for: Season 18
Reason for exit: Maksim Chmerkovskiy, a Dancing With the Stars veteran and ballroom dance expert, also joined the SYTYCD judging panel for season 18. His ballroom background and judging experience added another dimension to the panel. Similar to Holker and Siwa, there has been no official announcement regarding his future with the show beyond season 18.
Conclusion
The judges of So You Think You Can Dance have been integral to the show’s enduring appeal. The panel has seen many changes over its eighteen seasons, with judges leaving for various reasons, from contract disputes and career changes to personal tragedies and controversies. Each judge has brought their unique expertise and personality, contributing to the show’s legacy of discovering and celebrating exceptional dance talent. As SYTYCD continues to evolve, the judging panel will undoubtedly remain a focal point for fans eager to see who will guide the next generation of dancers to success.
