We’ve all heard it before, that seemingly simple yet incredibly daunting piece of advice: “Just be yourself!” It’s often offered as a comforting reassurance before stepping into new and potentially nerve-wracking situations – a new job, a first date, or even moving to a new city. While the sentiment is well-intended, the reality of “being yourself” is far more complex than those three little words suggest. There’s an inherent assumption that we possess a fully formed, readily accessible “self” just waiting to be unleashed. But what does it truly mean to be authentic, and how do we navigate the journey of self-discovery in a world that often pressures us to conform? Through the lens of pop music, particularly the vibrant soundscape of Gen Z artists, we can explore this very idea. And no one embodies this exploration quite like Chappell Roan, especially in her breakout hit, “Pink Pony Club,” with its infectious and empowering refrain to Keep On Dancing.
Humans are inherently social creatures, and our understanding of self is intricately woven into our experiences and interactions with others. From childhood friendships to adult relationships, we are constantly shaping and refining who we are based on our environments and the people around us. This process of self-discovery isn’t always straightforward; it’s filled with challenges and nuances that vary greatly depending on individual experiences and societal factors. Consider the different perspectives on friendship from a middle schooler navigating social cliques and a 40-year-old juggling work-life balance and maintaining connections – the hurdles are different, yet the underlying need for belonging and authentic connection remains. Furthermore, societal injustices rooted in race, gender, and other identity markers can significantly impact an individual’s ability and comfort in expressing their true selves.
Gen Z artists are increasingly using their music as a powerful medium to delve into themes of authenticity and self-expression. Chappell Roan stands out as a compelling example. Her journey, marked by both setbacks and triumphs, is a testament to the power of staying true to oneself. From initially signing with a record label only to be dropped, to captivating massive crowds at Lollapalooza in 2024 – reportedly drawing the largest audience ever for a performance – Roan’s rise to stardom is a captivating narrative of resilience and self-belief. Born Kayleigh Amstutz in a small, conservative Missouri town, she adopted the stage name Chappell Roan, inspired by her grandfather. Despite her upbringing in a community that held traditional values, Roan has become a prominent voice and contemporary queer icon, openly sharing her struggles to reconcile her upbringing with her evolving identity.
Her single “Pink Pony Club,” released at the onset of the COVID-19 pandemic, initially gained little traction and coincided with her being dropped from her record label. However, this perceived setback proved to be a turning point. Fast forward to August 2024, and “Pink Pony Club” has exploded in popularity, amassing over 130 million streams on Spotify alone. This underdog story resonates deeply with listeners, highlighting the power of perseverance and artistic vision.
“Pink Pony Club” narrates the story of a young woman yearning to escape her Tennessee surroundings for the allure of California. Knowing her aspirations might not align with her family’s expectations (“it won’t make mama proud”), she boldly chooses to pursue a life path that deviates from the norms of her upbringing. The fictitious Pink Pony Club becomes a potent symbol of rebellion and liberation – a place representing what was once considered taboo or forbidden, yet ultimately allows her to connect with a more authentic version of herself. While the song doesn’t explicitly define what “being herself” entails for the protagonist, the repeated lyric, “I’m gonna keep on dancing,” underscores her decision to embrace what resonates with her, regardless of external judgment or misunderstanding. This ambiguity is part of the song’s appeal; the very act of pursuing new experiences and embracing life’s uncertainties speaks to a universal desire for self-discovery. The call to keep on dancing becomes an anthem for pushing boundaries and living authentically.
Authenticity – aligning our lives with our values and embracing our true selves – is a cornerstone of mental well-being. The courage to keep on dancing to the beat of our own drum, even when it leads us away from familiar paths, is essential for personal growth and fulfillment. To delve deeper into the concept of authenticity and its impact on mental health, resources like Psychology Today offer valuable insights. Chappell Roan’s “Pink Pony Club” serves as a vibrant reminder that the journey to authenticity is a dance worth pursuing, encouraging us all to keep on dancing towards our truest selves.
